Editing Template talk:Spell table

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The edit can be undone. Please check the comparison below to verify that this is what you want to do, and then publish the changes below to finish undoing the edit.

Latest revision Your text
Line 1: Line 1:
== Attack/Save column not displaying correct information ==
== Attack/Save column not displaying correct information ==
Not sure if this would be a fix from this template or in the database, but it seems like the "Attack/Save" column does not display correctly. First, no spells or cantrips are indicated with "Attack roll" in that column, despite there being plenty of attack roll spells. Second, it seems as though only ''some'' Saves are displayed in that column. To take an example from the [[List of 1st level spells]] page - [[Bane (Spell)|Bane]] is a CHA save and [[Charm Person]] is a WIS save, but only Charm Person is indicated as a save in the table. --[[User:Willach|Willach]] ([[User talk:Willach|talk]]) 03:49, 11 January 2024 (CET)
Not sure if this would be a fix from this template or in the database, but it seems like the "Attack/Save" column does not display correctly. First, no spells or cantrips are indicated with "Attack roll" in that column, despite there being plenty of attack roll spells. Second, it seems as though only ''some'' Saves are displayed in that column. To take an example from the [[List of 1st level spells]] page - [[Bane (Spell)|Bane]] is a CHA save and [[Charm Person]] is a WIS save, but only Charm Person is indicated as a save in the table. --[[User:Willach|Willach]] ([[User talk:Willach|talk]]) 03:49, 11 January 2024 (CET)
Follow-up to this, I noticed that the corresponding pages had save info indicated differently in their [[Template:Spell page|Spell page template]]. This may impact the results of the database query for Saves. Here's some examples I found:
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! Spell !! Save effect !! Table save !! Actual Save !! Spell page notes
|-
| [[Animal Friendship]] || Prevent condition || WIS save || WIS save || "save" and "condition save" both had WIS. Main info box had "WIS Save" under "Details:" and condition info box had "Wisdom saving throw".
|-
| [[Compelled Duel]] || Prevent condition || ''(none)'' || WIS save || "save" had WIS, "condition save" had "Wisdom". Main info box had "WIS Save" under "Details:" and condition info box had "Wisdom saving throw".
|-
| [[Bane (Spell)|Bane]] || Prevent condition || ''(none)'' || CHA save || "condition save" had CHA, "save" was not populated. Main info box had no indication of Save, condition info box had "Charisma saving throw".
|-
| [[Grease]] || Prevent condition from terrain || DEX save || DEX save || "save" had DEX, "condition" was "Prone", "condition save" had "Dexterity". Main info box had "DEX Save" under "Details:", condition info box had "Dexterity saving throw", area info box did not indicate any Save.
|-
| [[Entangle]] || Prevent condition from terrain || ''(none)'' || STR save || "save" had STR, "condition" and "condition save" were not populated. Main info box had "STR Save" under "Details:".  No condition info box (area info box did not indicate any Save).
|-
| [[Arms of Hadar]] || Halve damage and prevent condition || STR save || STR save || "save" and "condition save" both had STR, "damage save" and "damage save effect" were not populated. Main info box had "STR Save" under "Details:", but no info about saves under "Damage:" ''(some other similar spells do)''. Condition info box had "Strength saving throw".
|-
| [[Thunderwave]] || Halve damage and prevent knockback || ''(none)'' || CON save || "save" had CON; "condition", "condition save", "damage save", and "damage save effect" were not populated. Main info box had "STR Save" under "Details:", but no info about saves under "Damage:" ''(some other similar spells do)''. No condition info box.
|-
| [[Hellish Rebuke]] || Halve damage || DEX save || DEX save || "damage save" had "Dexterity", "damage save effect" had "half", "save" was not populated. Main info box had no Save information under "Details:", but had "(Dexterity save to halve)" under "Damage:"
|-
| [[Burning Hands]] || Halve damage || ''(none)'' || DEX save || "save" had DEX, "damage save" and "damage save effect" were not populated. Main info box had "DEX Save" under "Details:", but no info about saves under "Damage:" ''(some other similar spells do)''.
|-
| [[Ice Knife]] || Halve extra damage after attack roll || ''(none)'' || DEX save || "save" had "DEX", "extra damage" was populated but "extra damage save" and "extra damage save effect" were not populated. Main info box had "DEX Save" under "Details:", but no info about saves under "Damage:".
|-
| [[Ray of Sickness]] || Prevent condition after attack roll || ''(none)'' || CON save || "save" and "damage save" were not populated, "condition save" had "Constitution". Main info box had no indication of Save, condition info box had "Constitution saving throw".
|}
''Apologies for the large table; I wanted to make sure I was thorough.''
Given what I found above, I conclude that the Spell table search will only display the corresponding save in the following conditions:
* Both "save" ''and'' "condition save" are populated. Both ''must'' be the three-letter abbreviation of an attribute (i.e. both must be "STR" instead of "Strength"), but seems as though the abbreviation restriction might not apply if "area" is populated?
* If "damage" is populated, "damage save" is populated. Attribute name does not need to be abbreviated.
Now the question comes, should the database, the search template, or each spell's individual pages be updated to populate the table appropriately? --[[User:Willach|Willach]] ([[User talk:Willach|talk]]) 05:23, 11 January 2024 (CET)
* I believe the problem comes from the spells missing the "save" parameter and only having the "condition save" specified. [[User:Nattern|Nattern]] ([[User talk:Nattern|talk]]) 09:45, 11 January 2024 (CET)
I updated the [[List of cantrips|Cantrips]] and [[List of 1st level spells|Level 1 spells]] and got most of them to have the appropriate saves show up in their respective tables. However, it seems like for spells that involve both an attack roll and a saving throw (such as [[Ray of Sickness]] and [[Searing Smite]]), there isn't a way to get that to display in the table. And I'm not sure how to get "Attack Roll" to display in the table either.
Somewhat unrelated, but I also noticed that the "Action + Bonus Action" spells (i.e. Hail of Thorns and the various Smites) only show the "Action" or "Bonus Action" icon in the table, but not both. I believe it showed both at some point previously; was the query and/or database updated? ---[[User:Willach|Willach]] ([[User talk:Willach|talk]]) 19:14, 11 January 2024 (CET)
Please note that all contributions to Baldur's Gate 3 Wiki are considered to be released under the CC BY-NC-SA license, except when noted otherwise (see BG3Wiki:Copyrights for details). If you do not want your writing to be edited and redistributed at will, do not submit it here. Per our Content Rules, you are promising that you wrote this yourself, or copied it from a public domain or similar free resource. Do not submit copyrighted work without permission!

To edit this page, please answer the question that appears below (more info):

Cancel Editing help (opens in new window)
Retrieved from "https://bg3.wiki/wiki/Template_talk:Spell_table"