User talk:Bgwny1134: Difference between revisions
Latest comment: 7 June by Rydiak in topic Edit Notes
No edit summary |
(response to anon & reformat) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Edit Notes == | == Edit Notes == | ||
=== The Pointy Hat === | === [[The Pointy Hat]] === | ||
* https://bg3.wiki/w/index.php?title=The_Pointy_Hat&oldid=189250&diff=prev | * https://bg3.wiki/w/index.php?title=The_Pointy_Hat&oldid=189250&diff=prev | ||
** Removed reference to YT creator, even though it may be relevant to the item itself. Referencing creators is a slippery slope as once folks start doing it, this site will become an SEO vector for BG3 content creators. Better to not reference them at all, IMO. | ** Removed reference to YT creator, even though it may be relevant to the item itself. Referencing creators is a slippery slope as once folks start doing it, this site will become an SEO vector for BG3 content creators. Better to not reference them at all, IMO. | ||
=== Boney === | === [[Boney]] === | ||
* Why remove the Quote? - 62.204.40.43 //pxd | * Why remove the Quote? - 62.204.40.43 //pxd | ||
** You really need an explanation on why the quote was removed given the context you added it in? Comparing a religion in the Real World to a race of characters in DnD/Forgotten Realms has no place on this wiki. [[User:Rydiak|Rydiak]] ([[User talk:Rydiak|talk]]) 18:09, 7 June 2024 (CEST) | ** You really need an explanation on why the quote was removed given the context you added it in? Comparing a religion in the Real World to a race of characters in DnD/Forgotten Realms has no place on this wiki. [[User:Rydiak|Rydiak]] ([[User talk:Rydiak|talk]]) 18:09, 7 June 2024 (CEST) | ||
** What Rydiak said. The Wiki should only contain information that is directly relevant to gameplay, whether in 5e or BG3. Discussions related to real-world sociological issues are not relevant to this wiki. Feel free to add the quote itself to the article, but speculation on the real-world implication of the quote is not necessary. [[User:Bgwny1134|Bgwny1134]] ([[User talk:Bgwny1134|talk]]) | ** What Rydiak said. The Wiki should only contain information that is directly relevant to gameplay, whether in 5e or BG3. Discussions related to real-world sociological issues are not relevant to this wiki. Feel free to add the quote itself to the article, but speculation on the real-world implication of the quote is not necessary. [[User:Bgwny1134|Bgwny1134]] ([[User talk:Bgwny1134|talk]]) | ||
Revision as of 19:46, 8 June 2024
Edit Notes
The Pointy Hat
- https://bg3.wiki/w/index.php?title=The_Pointy_Hat&oldid=189250&diff=prev
- Removed reference to YT creator, even though it may be relevant to the item itself. Referencing creators is a slippery slope as once folks start doing it, this site will become an SEO vector for BG3 content creators. Better to not reference them at all, IMO.
Boney
- Why remove the Quote? - 62.204.40.43 //pxd
- You really need an explanation on why the quote was removed given the context you added it in? Comparing a religion in the Real World to a race of characters in DnD/Forgotten Realms has no place on this wiki. Rydiak (talk) 18:09, 7 June 2024 (CEST)
- What Rydiak said. The Wiki should only contain information that is directly relevant to gameplay, whether in 5e or BG3. Discussions related to real-world sociological issues are not relevant to this wiki. Feel free to add the quote itself to the article, but speculation on the real-world implication of the quote is not necessary. Bgwny1134 (talk)