Editing Talk:Permanent bonuses

'''Mirror of Loss'''

I think these bonuses need to be clarified a bit better. The sacrifice of "memories" can provide either a +1 OR +2 bonus, depending on some factor (seemingly using the Arcane check provides +1, while using a religion check provides +2, and apparently they can stack for a +3 total, though I have no save to verify this at the moment). The way it's currently worded implies sacrificing "memories" is only +1, which I can say for certain is not true based on my testing in my original run (where I got +2 after the Religion check, but either never had (or failed and didn't notice) an an Arcane check).
: As a rogue/ranger, I didn't see any option for an Arcana check either. I'm honestly not sure what the recent edit to this permanent bonus info is trying to say, since I'm only aware of the +2 bonus option, so I'm hesitant to correct anything here. Anyone else have concrete, confirmed steps for how to achieve both a +1 and a +2 bonus from the mirror? -[[User:Majesstic|majesstic]] ([[User talk:Majesstic|talk]]) 11:15, 23 August 2023 (CEST)
: As a followup, I did a bunch of testing here, and it seems like only +1 CHA is possible and it's quite buggy/inconsistent. Maybe others can chime in to comment on other outcomes? Possibly class-tagged dialogue options for an Arcana check? -[[User:Majesstic|majesstic]] ([[User talk:Majesstic|talk]]) 12:51, 23 August 2023 (CEST)
:: sorry first time posting on this wiki, so apologies if i dont follow convention. just want to add to this... I dont think this is a bug, i think theirs a hidden role being done even if you pass the checks. I did prayer, then another religion check and sacrificed fortitude each test (im a wizard so i passed each check). 7 times i got the "you think of Aver" dialogue, which means you get nothing except the debuff. 4 times I got the straight exchange, 2 fort down for 2 int up and 2 times I got the Patriars buff, which gave em +1 cha and then allowed me to interact again and get a +2 int for sacrificing Thay knowledge. What i rolled on previous checks seemed to have no bearing on what the mirror did as long as i passed them. (in one case i got 2 nat 20's and still i got the Aver dialogue and got nothing), I therefore think this is indicative of a third role being made on mirror's side and this is indicating crit fails, passes and crit success roles and i think thats why its random, not a bug. 

'''Awakened'''

This one probably needs more information on what happens if you have Lae'zel use the device when she's a companion. In my playthrough, she received three negative conditions & her saving throw results are not visible to the player.
: I can confirm it can penalize 3 stats: CON, INT and WIS. Lae'zel was not even in my party.

== Act 2 potion ==

The potion gained from convincing Astarion to bite the drow appears to be tied to race. My halfling received a potion of Halfling luck which gave advantage on skill checks until long rest. Need confirmation from other races that have received different potions.
:You get two potions from her. The first is 'free' for allowing her to take a sample of YOUR blood, and that varies based on your race. Then there's a second potion you get from convincing Astarion to bite her, which is the permanent +2 STR one. Only the latter is listed here, since it's permanent. The others are listed on the [[Araj Oblodra]] page. [[User:Hargrimm|Hargrimm]] ([[User talk:Hargrimm|talk]]) 02:45, 26 August 2023 (CEST)

== Brand of the Absolute ==

I reverted the recent change to the note and added some clarity. You can still brand your full party after the first character has been branded by [[Gut]]. [[Warlock Greez]] handles all of the branding after that. -[[User:Majesstic|majesstic]] ([[User talk:Majesstic|talk]]) 01:27, 27 August 2023 (CEST)

== Patriar's Memory ==

Might be linked to reading the Patriar Blackmail, etc books under the House of Grief.

== Add "Summon Us" ==

Given that this page has added Find Familiar: Scratch and Find Familiar: Cheeky Quasit, it may as well add that you can permanently be able to Summon Us, a friendly Intellect Devourer with better stats and attacks, in Act 2 within the Mind Flayer colony if you saved them during the Game's opening sequence/tutorial. You must free it from its cage within the Chopping room/Morgue of the Mind Flayer Colony to be able to receive its summon item, which is a brain that takes up an inventory slot and grants the ability to Summon Us. Transferring the Brain between characters transfers the summoning spell to that character. Note, however, that Us does not seem to be the same type of spell as that of Scratch or Cheeky Quasit; that is, it is not a Find Familiar spell and instead is labelled a "Cantrip". Us can be resummoned upon death in battle after a short rest, making them a permanent summon.

== Mirror of Loss ==

You can deceive Mirror of Loss, so you don't have to sacrifice Forbidden Knowledge to get, +1 CHA and +2 to other.

== Awakened ==

Mountain Pass location counts as Act 2.
: No it does not. Act Two only begins when you enter the shadow-cursed lands zone, via the exit from either the Mountain Pass or Grymforge. That's when the achievement for leaving Act One pops as well. [[User:Hargrimm|Hargrimm]] ([[User talk:Hargrimm|talk]]) 20:13, 26 September 2023 (CEST)
:: I got the A2 achievement when entering the Mountain Pass (on GOG), but I do believe that's a mistake because Larian mentions Mountain Pass events as part of A1 changes in their patch notes. The achievement triggering for some players when entering the Mountain Pass is likely the source of the confusion about when A2 actually starts

:: Entering Underdark does not result warning about advancing story line. Entering Mountain Pass shows that warning. Elminster shows up in Mountain Pass or after using Underdark elevator to Shadow lands. By that logic Mountain Pass is Act 2.

== Mystra's Benevolence == 

The tooltip doesn't mention it, but many people reported it lasts until the next long rest and thus isn't permanent. I tested it myself and the buff is really gone after resting, the combat log no longer mentions advantage like it did before resting.
Some claim it's a bug, but whether or not that's true it's not how a permanent buff now, so it shouldn't be listed

== Missing permanent bonus ==

Patriar's memory +1 CHA from mirror of loss.

Getting it it's random and convoluted, [https://www.reddit.com/r/BaldursGate3/comments/166dq9n/act%203%20mirror%20of%20loss%20strategy%20for%20stat%20increases/ in this reddit post] it's explained how to get it

== Mystra's Benevolence ==

Not permanent as of Patch 3 - leaves after long rest.

== Mirror of Loss bonuses patch 3 hotfix 7 ==

I was able to get the +3 bonus on all characters in my party. Each was able to complete one after another.

== Multiple Shovels (Find Familiar: Cheeky Quasit) ==

I was able to get Shovel on my Tav and Gale with this setup ''(not sure if all or only some of the following is needed)'':
* Shovel was first summoned in Act I, before entering the Mountain Pass (or even the Underdark).
* Shovel was first summoned in the middle of the Emerald Grove, so it is not a requirement to summon Shovel in the Apothecary's Cellar  or Whispering Depths.
* My Tav was a Wood Elf, and had 1 level in Wizard (none in Warlock or Sorcerer).
* My Tav had already successfully read the [[Necromancy of Thay]] (gaining the Forbidden Knowledge bonus) before summoning Shovel (or even scribing the scroll).
** You may be able to read through the book after the initial Shovel summoning; haven't tested that.
Here's what I did:
# Gale scribed the scroll to his Wizard spellbook, and cast the summoning spell. Gale had the initial conversation with Shovel (even if I quickly switched to Tav after casting, the game would automatically switch back to Gale and initiate the conversation).
# During the initial conversation, Gale said "Your name is 'Shovel'?" followed by "Shovel is fine" when offered to change the name. ''(This may or may not be required, but was mentioned on the [[Scroll of Summon Quasit|scroll's page]].)''
# After the initial conversation, my Tav talked to (Gale's) Shovel. She said a line starting with "Oh, oh, a spell shite!", and Tav learned how to summon Shovel.
# Tav summoned Shovel using the newly learned spell. Gale's Shovel did not disappear, so the party now had two Shovels.
With this setup, Gale had the spell "Find Familiar: Cheeky Quasit" in the Wizard section of his spellbook (i.e. it would be lost when re-speccing), and Tav had the spell "Find Familiar: Cheeky Quasit" in the Common section of their spellbook (i.e. it would persist if re-speccing).
[[User:Willach|Willach]] ([[User talk:Willach|talk]]) 00:07, 6 November 2023 (CET)

== Mystra's Benevolence ==

The Ritual Circle in Balth's hidden room gives Mystra's Benevolence to Gale (adv on Concentration checks), theres a page for it, but missing on this page.

You can only get Benevolence or the Shadow Spell Slot. But you can get the Blessing (ends on rest) and Benevolence together. You can also get Benevolence with Gale as just a companion.

== Volo's Eye edit suggestion ==

Hey!  I don't know who reads or edits these, but I was playing on Xbox Series X, and I was playing the Dark Urge campaign, as a dragonborn.  I got Volo's eye, and thought it really clashed with my character's other eye, but while trying to edit the eyes, I found out that you CAN edit Volo's eye if you select the heterochromia option, and specifically change the right eye.  It won't go back to the original color, but you can change it's colors there.  Just an FYI!

== Presentation of information ==
This article, in its current structure, does not support a table, which only limits the accessibility on the article (see the [[Help: Style manual#Tables|style manual for examples]]). The article would need to be rewritten to support a table, most likely by removing information already found on the artifle for each respective bonus, which may or may not improve the articles.[[User:Willowisp|Willowisp]] ([[User talk:Willowisp|talk]]) 08:42, 4 February 2024 (CET)
: [[User:Willowisp|Willowisp]] As you said yourself, use this articles Talk page to air dispute and at least try to reach a consensus before undoing contributions. I converted the page to support a table, and you reverted it. I tested the table on mobile and it works just fine, like the dozens of other articles on the wiki using a table. If you have an explicit accessibility concern, raise it here or contribute to the page (constructively) yourself to make a fix (see [[BG3Wiki:Editing_policy#Conduct]] In the case of disputes and conflicts, it is always the goal to reach a consensus to improve the wiki, rather than to follow a list of arbitrary rules.)[[User:Korgat|Korgat]]
:: The table was previously removed due to the potential issues it presented, and a consensus was reached. Due to the wide range of devices on which users visit this website, it is not possible to know how an article will appear to other users, and what looks fine on one's owb device may look substantially different on other devices. That's why we have the style guidelines that we do – and broadly speaking, we avoid tables which aren't simply tabular lists or spreadsheets. Obviously, there may be a version of the page where the table works better, but it isn't feasible with the prosey descriptions of each permanent bonus. For examples of accessibility issues with the table, it was lacking in row/col scopes and headers, and contained paragraphs of text instead of a few sentences, per cell. [[User:Willowisp|Willowisp]] ([[User talk:Willowisp|talk]]) 21:50, 4 February 2024 (CET)